How to Conduct a Systematic Review for Your Australian Thesis
Dr Michael Torres · 2024-10-10 · 9 min read · Research Methods
A step-by-step guide to systematic review methodology following PRISMA guidelines, tailored for Australian postgraduate students.
Introduction
Systematic reviews are increasingly valued in Australian postgraduate research, particularly in health sciences, education, and social policy. Unlike traditional literature reviews, systematic reviews follow a rigorous, transparent methodology to identify, evaluate, and synthesise all relevant research on a specific question. This guide walks you through the process.
What Is a Systematic Review?
A systematic review is a research method that:
Uses a **pre-defined, documented search strategy**
Applies **explicit inclusion and exclusion criteria**
**Critically appraises** the quality of included studies
**Synthesises** findings using a transparent method
Is **reproducible** — another researcher following your protocol should reach similar results
When to Use a Systematic Review
A systematic review is appropriate when:
You want to comprehensively map the evidence on a specific question
You need to inform policy or practice with the best available evidence
Previous reviews on the topic are outdated or incomplete
Your research question is well-defined and answerable through existing literature
The PRISMA Framework
The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) provides the gold standard for reporting. The PRISMA 2020 statement includes:
A 27-item checklist for transparent reporting
A flow diagram showing study selection
Guidance on registering your protocol
Step-by-Step Process
1. Define Your Research Question
Use the PICO framework (or PICo for qualitative reviews):
**P**opulation: Who?
**I**ntervention/Interest: What?
**C**omparison: Compared to what?
**O**utcome: What effect?
**Example:** "What is the effectiveness of peer mentoring programs (I) compared to standard support (C) on academic retention (O) among first-generation university students in Australia (P)?"
2. Register Your Protocol
Register your protocol on PROSPERO (for health-related reviews) or OSF (for other disciplines) before conducting the review. This demonstrates transparency and prevents duplication.
3. Develop Your Search Strategy
Identify relevant databases (Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, ERIC, Informit, PsycINFO)
Develop search terms using Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT)
Include synonyms, truncation, and MeSH/subject headings
Document every search string and date
4. Screen Studies
**Title and abstract screening:** Apply inclusion/exclusion criteria to identify potentially relevant studies
**Full-text screening:** Read full texts to confirm eligibility
Use screening tools like Covidence or Rayyan
Have a second reviewer independently screen a subset (ideally all) to reduce bias
5. Extract Data
Create a standardised data extraction form including:
Study characteristics (authors, year, country, design)
Participant characteristics
Intervention/exposure details
Outcome measures
Key findings
6. Assess Quality
Use appropriate quality assessment tools:
**RCTs:** Cochrane Risk of Bias tool (RoB 2)
**Observational studies:** Newcastle-Ottawa Scale
**Qualitative studies:** Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP)
**Mixed methods:** Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT)
7. Synthesise Findings
**Meta-analysis:** Statistical pooling of quantitative results (if studies are sufficiently similar)
**Narrative synthesis:** Structured description and comparison of findings
**Thematic synthesis:** For qualitative systematic reviews (Thomas & Harden, 2008)
8. Report Using PRISMA
Include the PRISMA flow diagram and complete the checklist.
Tips for Australian Postgraduate Students
1. **Include Australian databases** — Informit indexes Australian and New Zealand publications not always captured by international databases
2. **Seek librarian support** — University research librarians can help refine your search strategy
3. **Allow sufficient time** — A thorough systematic review takes 6–12 months
4. **Consider it as a thesis chapter** — A published systematic review can serve as your literature review chapter
5. **Use reference management software** — Export search results directly into EndNote or Zotero
Conclusion
A well-conducted systematic review demonstrates methodological rigour and makes a valuable contribution to evidence-based practice. DissertlyPro can assist with search strategy development, quality assessment, and writing up your systematic review.